Call Us Now
Email Us Now
📢 Major Update: The Department of Homeland Security has proposed the biggest shake-up to the H-1B lottery system in decades. While the rule isn't finalized yet, you need to start planning as though these changes are coming: because they probably are.
The days of every H-1B application having equal odds in the lottery could be numbered. Instead, your chances of getting selected would depend heavily on one thing: how much your employer is willing to pay you.
What's Actually Changing?
On September 24, 2025, USCIS dropped a bombshell proposal that would completely restructure how H-1B visas are awarded. The public comment period closed on October 24, 2025, and now we're waiting to see if this becomes reality.
Here's the core change: Instead of a random lottery where everyone has roughly the same 30% chance of selection, your application would get multiple entries based on your wage level. Think of it like buying multiple lottery tickets: the higher your salary, the more tickets you get.
How the New Weighted H-1B Lottery Works
The proposed system assigns lottery entries based on Department of Labor wage levels for your specific job, location, and industry:
Level IV (Fully Competent): 4 lottery entries
- Positions paying at the 67th percentile or higher
- New probability: 61.16% chance of selection
Level III (Experienced): 3 lottery entries
- Positions paying between 50th-67th percentiles
- New probability: 45.87% chance of selection
Level II (Qualified): 2 lottery entries
- Positions paying between 34th-50th percentiles
- New probability: 30.58% chance of selection
Level I (Entry Level): 1 lottery entry
- Positions paying at 34th percentile or below
- New probability: 15.29% chance of selection
To put this in perspective: A Level IV position would have four times better odds than a Level I position. That's not a small advantage: it's game-changing.
Who Wins and Who Loses?
The Winners: High-Wage Applicants
If you're being offered a senior-level position or work in high-paying markets like San Francisco or New York, this system heavily favors you. Level IV applicants would see their odds jump from 30% to over 61%: more than doubling their chances.
Tech companies offering six-figure salaries to experienced engineers? They're celebrating. Investment banks hiring quantitative analysts? They love this change.
The Losers: Entry-Level Workers and Recent Graduates
Here's the harsh reality: if you're a recent graduate or taking an entry-level position, your odds would drop by 42%: from about 30% to just 15%. That's a massive decrease that could fundamentally alter your career trajectory.
This particularly impacts:
- Recent college graduates
- Workers in lower cost-of-living areas
- Employees at nonprofits or smaller organizations
- Essential workers in healthcare or education with modest salaries
What This Means for Startups and Small Businesses
Small businesses are getting hit hard by this proposal. In fiscal year 2024, over 17,000 small entities filed H-1B petitions subject to the lottery process. Many of these companies hire at Level I or Level II wage levels because they're:
- Located in areas with lower costs of living
- Operating with tighter budgets
- Hiring recent graduates they plan to train and develop
The financial impact is staggering: USCIS estimates some small businesses could face costs of approximately $85,000 when they lose access to a single Level I worker due to reduced lottery odds.
For startup founders reading this, you need to seriously reconsider your H-1B strategy. The old approach of hiring talented recent graduates at competitive-but-modest salaries may no longer work.
Your H-1B Strategy Needs to Change Now
Even though the rule isn't finalized, smart applicants and employers are already adapting:
For Employers:
- Reevaluate salary structures: Consider whether you can justify higher wage levels for positions
- Geographic strategy: Factor in how location affects wage level determinations
- Alternative visa paths: Research O-1 visas for exceptional ability or L-1 visas for international transfers
- Early planning: Start salary discussions now for 2026 applications
For Applicants:
- Research wage levels: Use the Department of Labor's OEWS database to understand where your position falls
- Negotiate strategically: If possible, negotiate for responsibilities and salary that bump you to a higher wage level
- Consider location: The same job in different cities can fall into different wage levels
- Have backup plans: With lower odds for entry-level positions, explore other immigration options
The Bigger Picture: Why This Change Matters
This isn't just about lottery odds: it's about who gets to participate in the American economy and innovation ecosystem.
The argument for weighted selection: Proponents say it prioritizes truly skilled workers and prevents wage suppression. They argue that random selection doesn't serve national economic interests.
The case against: Critics worry this creates a system that favors wealth over talent, potentially excluding brilliant individuals who happen to work in modestly-paid but essential roles. It could also reduce diversity in the H-1B program, limiting opportunities for workers from different backgrounds and industries.
Geographic implications are particularly concerning. A software engineer in Austin might be classified as Level III, while the same role in San Francisco qualifies as Level I: not because of different skills, but because of different regional wage scales.
What Happens Next?
The comment period closed on October 24, 2025, and DHS is now reviewing thousands of public comments. The Small Business Administration specifically requested feedback on:
- How many small businesses would be affected
- Alternative approaches (like separate small business lotteries)
- Real costs of compliance
Timeline uncertainty: We don't have a firm date for when this rule might be finalized. It could be months: or it could be implemented for the next lottery cycle in March 2025.
Taking Action in an Uncertain Time
The reality is that you need to plan for both scenarios: the current random system and the proposed weighted system.
If you're applying in 2026:
- Research your wage level classification now
- Discuss salary positioning with your employer
- Prepare alternative immigration strategies
- Stay informed about rule finalization
If you're an employer:
- Audit your current H-1B salary practices
- Model how the weighted system would affect your selection rates
- Consider whether salary adjustments make business sense
- Explore other visa categories for critical hires
This proposed change represents the most significant shift in H-1B policy in years. Whether you love it or hate it, ignoring it isn't an option. The H-1B lottery has always been competitive: but now it might become a game where your salary determines how many chances you get to play.
We'll keep monitoring developments and update you as soon as the final rule is published. In immigration law, being prepared isn't just smart; it's essential for your future in America.
Disclaimer: This analysis is for informational purposes and doesn't constitute legal advice. Immigration rules are complex and change frequently: consult with a qualified immigration attorney for guidance on your specific situation. Each case has unique circumstances that may affect eligibility and strategy. For personalized guidance on your specific situation, contact Badmus & Associates at 214-393-4917 to discuss your immigration options.
